Serving or Suffering: The Dichotomy of Piscean Existence

The phrase “Pisces is born to either serve or suffer” reflects a common interpretation within astrology that associates certain personality traits and life paths with specific zodiac signs. In the case of Pisces, this interpretation suggests that individuals born under this sign have a fundamental inclination towards either serving others or experiencing suffering, and these two paths are intricately linked.  Astrologers who support this viewpoint argue that the inherent characteristics of Pisces, symbolized by the fish and associated with the element of water, align with notions of compassion, empathy, and sensitivity. These qualities supposedly predispose Pisces individuals to find fulfillment and purpose through serving others. Additionally, Pisces is ruled by Neptune, a planet often linked to spirituality, creativity, and transcendence. The 12th house, often connected to Pisces, is also associated with the subconscious, hidden matters, and selfless service. However, the idea that Pisces individuals are destined to serve or suffer does not account for the vast diversity of personalities, experiences, and life choices within this zodiac sign. People are complex and multifaceted, influenced by various factors such as upbringing, personal experiences, education, and environment. Not all Pisces individuals are naturally inclined towards selfless service, nor do they necessarily face a life of suffering if they don’t fulfill this role.

In essence, while the phrase “Pisces is born to either serve or suffer” is a compelling and poetic concept within astrology, it should be taken as one perspective among many. Individuals, regardless of their zodiac signs, have the power to define their own purpose, goals, and paths in life. The intersection of astrology and personal agency remains a topic of ongoing discussion and philosophical debate.

Fishes Swimming in Opposite Directions

The representation of Pisces as two fish swimming in opposite directions on the zodiac wheel holds a symbolic significance that astrologers often associate with the duality and complexity of this zodiac sign. This portrayal reflects the dichotomy that is often observed in Pisces individuals, where they are believed to be torn between opposing forces and directions in life. The astrological concept that those born under the Pisces sign either swim upstream towards a meaningful life or are pulled downwards by the undercurrent into a wasted existence highlights the idea of choice and the potential for both positive and negative outcomes. This dichotomy is not necessarily meant to suggest that there is no middle ground, but rather to emphasize the contrasting paths that Pisces individuals might navigate throughout their lives.

Astrologers often characterize Pisces as being filled with inner confusion and experiencing a multitude of emotional and spiritual pulls. This inner conflict is thought to contribute to the complexity of their nature. Their tendency to move in ways that might be perplexing to others is seen as a reflection of their unique approach to life. The life of a Piscean is characterized by a perpetual quest for profound understanding and significance, as nothing unfolds simply or distinctly in their journey.

Pisces have a special connection to the unconscious, dreams, and fantasies speaks to their intuitive and imaginative nature. This connection to the unseen realms is thought to provide them with insights that others might not readily comprehend. Pisces individuals are often believed to possess an inner world that is rich with unexplored mysteries. Their introverted and withdrawn tendencies can be seen as a way to protect this inner world and engage in introspective exploration

The belief that Pisces individuals should give from the heart is rooted in the idea that their compassionate and empathetic nature naturally inclines them towards helping others. Their strong emotional connection to those around them often drives them to contribute positively to the lives of others. However, the potential downside of this inclination is the possibility of neglecting their own needs and happiness in the process.

Astrologers advocating for Pisces to lessen their attention on personal matters are regrettably misguided. Frequently, such an approach compels them to compromise their own well-being, ultimately paving the way for the foreseen negativity of “suffering,” discontent, and the associated unhappiness that is often predicted.

Astrologer Liz Greene’s perspective on the signs ruled by outer planets—Scorpio, Aquarius, and Pisces—adds an additional layer of complexity to the discussion. Greene suggests that these signs are connected to larger collective issues and themes that transcend individual concerns. This could imply that individuals born under these signs might feel a sense of responsibility or calling to address broader societal or spiritual matters.

Greene’s viewpoint also implies that these signs might have a more challenging time fitting into what could be considered an “ordinary life” due to their deeper connection to the collective and their inclination to engage with more profound and transformative forces. This perspective suggests that the standard patterns of personal and social existence might not fully encompass the complexities and aspirations of these signs.

At any rate, I feel there is a necessity in Scorpio, Aquarius Pisces to find someplace in reality that extends beyond the purely personal sphere. Otherwise I think these signs can become terribly negative. They have the worst reputations of all the zodiac. The classic charge against Pisces is that of drugs and alcohol, and as far as I have seen, this is perfectly true. A great many Pisceans drown in that water, not because the sign is innately alcoholic, but because they are thirsting for something beyond a wholly material perception of reality. The opening of the door might come through a strong religious aspiration, or a creative outlet such as music or poetry or acting, or an experience of the unity of life that comes through service of some kind. But if the door is never opened, the only way to the spirit is through spirits, if you will excuse the horrible pun. Even if Pisces wants to go and study computers or become a civil servant, he must have some place in his life for the myths and the music and the poetry and the imagination. There are a good many pathetic Pisceans wandering about trying desperately to become good accountants or stock brokers or insurance agents wondering why they feel hopeless and depressed and lethargic while their Taurean and Capricornian compatriots really enjoy their jobs. By Liz Greene, The Outer Planets & Their Cycles

Pisces individuals have a unique and profound relationship with their inner world and should seek outlets that allow them to express and engage with their imaginative and emotional nature. Pisceans might suffer if they fail to find joy and purpose in the earthly realm is aligned with the idea that neglecting their emotional and spiritual needs can lead to feelings of emptiness, unfulfillment, and a sense of being disconnected from their true selves. This idea emphasizes the importance of recognizing and nurturing their creative and introspective inclinations.

For Pisces individuals, finding meaningful outlets for their imaginative and feeling nature can take many forms. It might involve creative pursuits such as art, music, writing, or other forms of self-expression that allow them to channel their rich inner world into tangible creations. Engaging with spiritual practices, meditation, or exploring their dreams could also provide avenues for them to connect with their deeper selves.

However, it’s important to strike a balance between nurturing their imaginative side and addressing practical realities. While embracing their unique qualities is essential, finding ways to integrate their inner world with the outer world is equally crucial for their overall well-being. This might involve seeking opportunities that align with their strengths and values, while still allowing them to explore their dreams and passions.

Ultimately, every individual, Piscean or not, faces the challenge of finding their purpose and achieving a sense of fulfillment. Astrological insights can serve as valuable guides in this journey, but personal growth and self-discovery are ongoing processes that involve a combination of inner exploration, life experiences, and self-awareness. The key is to recognize and honor one’s unique qualities while navigating the complexities of the world around them.

Katherine Merlin says,

The urge to get beyond – or free from – the demands of the ego drives Pisces toward transcendent glory, or escapism. These Sun signs are also notorious dreamers and drifters; mundane reality holds little meaning for them and potentially they may become channels for energy which is deeply universal and healing or thrill-seekers forever chasing an elusive, and impractical fantasy. The possibilities within this Sun sign actually conflict since the Neptunian urge which breaks down boundaries and dissolves self, can manifest destructively or constructively depending on whether the self is broken down in service of a higher ideal or simply broken down. The urge to give the self over is so strong for this sign that Pisces is renowned for its gullibility and lack of worldliness; for succumbing to the role of victim. For Pisces, the greatest challenge seems to lie in fixing on a truly worthwhile dream: a union which partakes of the Divine and can therefore carry the self aloft to a plane that transcends the separate state.